This election cycle, Catholic Americans are presented with the hair-raising choice between Hillary Clinton, who has a long history of supporting non-negotiables of the Catholic life ethic in addition to other rather shady skeletons in her closet, and Donald Trump, whose crude speech, narcissistic airs, and flagrant use of inflammatory rhetoric make many shudder to pull the lever in his favor. Being unable to read the future, it is difficult for many of these voters to decide with certainty which one of these individuals will be “the lesser of two evils”.
This year has seen a pendulum swing of Catholics caught between two currents, struggling to swim upstream while still satisfying their consciences. For many, neither choice is a conscionable one, and they will wind up voting third party, utilizing the write-in ballot, or simply staking out on the couch with a bowl of popcorn. Others will meander back to the Democrats, under the premise that they have something of an automatic dispensation due to what they perceive to be a dangerous level of incompetence on the part of the Republican candidate. Still others will hold their noses and vote the Trump ticket, hoping and praying that his side-kicks can keep him in line lest all Armageddon break lose over an insult to his hair-style!
But for all of us, this is a waiting game, and the drawn-out contest can easily cause an epidemic of political sea-sickness. Either way it goes, I have a feeling most Catholics will simultaneously breathe a sigh of relief that it wasn’t the one, and release a groan of anguish that it was the other. It’s really a rather helpless feeling to know things have gotten this bad, and there’s nothing immediate we can do to fix it. Frankly, I think it’s about time we had an alternative party to choose from which was pro-life across the board in accordance with Catholic social teaching, even if it takes a while to get off the ground. But alas and alack, it has not happened as of yet.
So…what are we supposed to do for the time being (other than clutch a teddy bear and dive under a fuzzy blanket until it’s all over)? As Catholics, maybe this is all an opportunity for us to appreciate that this world is not our real home, and we are always in the hands of Divine Providence. God knows better than we do how to handle this situation, and all others for that matter, and I personally find myself praying that He will do just that as opposed to sending up partisan intentions based on my own inadequate summations. Meanwhile, perhaps it is time to take a cue from the lives of the saints.
In the month of October, we celebrate the feasts of both St. Therese of Lisieux and St. Francis of Assisi. The former is remembered best for her “Little Way” of living the life of grace through everyday acts of self-sacrificial love, and the latter for his embrace of “Lady Poverty” and communion with all the elements of creation as his brothers and sisters. These two role models of the devout life stand out as the antithesis of what our culture tells us we need for our salvation. When we transform public servants into demigods, we have truly turned the world upside down from its natural order. When people proclaim “In Trump We Trust” as the new motto of a populist revolution, but rail against Pope Francis for washing the feet of a Muslim refugee woman clutching a baby in her arms on Holy Thursday, are eyes have grown scales that must be cleansed away before we can hope to see the Face of God.
But these saints of October are particularly beloved because they radiated the theological virtues of faith, hope, and charity through an embrace of humility, simplicity, and a respect for all life in their daily lives. They changed the world by allowing the Sacred Heart to beat in their own hearts, helping them to recognize every stage and condition of life as being singularly precious, brought forth and sustained by the Threefold Maker of Wonders. This is particularly appropriate, since October is also the month of Respect Life Sunday, a pro-life initiative which, in its proper context, should not be seen as exclusively dealing with the plight of the unborn.
The Catholic understanding of respecting life is just as much talking about the desperate migrant and the fleeing refugee and the frightened unwed mother. It is talking about the neglected elderly and the taunted disabled and the condemned imprisoned. It is talking about the sufferers of abuse and war, the addicts and drunks and prostitutes stumbling through a haze and selling themselves cheap, the isolated and abandoned of every walk of life. Yes, it is talking about the homosexual and transgender members of our community who need the love of Christ in their lives as much as anyone else. It is about you and me, and even those who despise us and wish us ill.
Last but not least, it is about those candidates we find so repugnant to our sensibilities. We must not allow this distaste for their policies and behaviors to turn into hatred for their personhood. They are immortal souls, just as we are, and we are integrally bound up with them. Christ shed His blood just as much for them as for us. If we cannot manage to look into their eyes and see past the façade to the core of their beings, we should spend more time reconciling ourselves to our own reflections in the mirror. We must ask: does it reflect the image of Christ as it should?
Heroism has been called “the glorious triumph of the spirit over the flesh.” Perhaps that also could be used as a description for holiness, although I would prefer say it restores our flesh to the way it is supposed to be, working in harmony with the spirit, as opposed a war between body and soul. This can only be achieved by a continual response to grace offered to us. Like Therese and Francis, we must remember that every seemingly insignificant act has eternal ramifications and defines our identities and destinies. We live in this world to grow closer to God and to one another in love. We must always be mindful of this universal call.
The eyes of love must see through race, color, creed, and lifestyle choices. We may heartily disagree with those choices, but never cease to see the worth that rests at the center of the free will, and recognize the soul made in the divine image, from the moment of conception to natural death. This is the heart of the Catholic teaching. It has been said that we are a religion of romantics; we believe in true love, and transformative love, in our own lives, our communities, our country, and the world.
We are all sinners, and yet we know that while hating sin, we must love ourselves and every other person as Christ loves us, even to the point of suffocating on a tree. It is not an easy road of dragging our small wooden crosses, of reaching out beyond our comfort zones and engaging a culture too often courting the ways of indifference and death in the name of the God of Life, and telling it to throw down its crutches and walk. But nothing worthwhile has ever had an easy-fix solution attached. We may find ourselves sweating blood by the end of the day, but it will bring forth lasting fruits in the garden beyond all ages.
So this election year, I call upon all my fellow Catholics, and fellow American citizens as a whole, to renew your commitment to overcome evil with good on a daily basis. Give yourself over to the work at hand of bringing the Kingdom of God to earth in the hearts of all you encounter. Instead of indulging in the political bear-baiting like a gladiatorial sport, turn your mind to higher things. Store up your treasures in Heaven, for where your treasure lies, there also lies your heart, and no vote can ever take that away.
Kings are not elected by Popular vote, but brought to power through warfare by those who wish the King to take the throne. The Kingdom of God is brought into the world by those who pray “Thy Kingdom Come, Thy will be done, on EARTH as it is in Heaven.
I appreciate this in-depth reflection and spiritual analysis and comparison of our two presidential candidates. I noticed that when making your comparisons your concerns regarding Trump were focused on his personality, whereas your concerns regarding Clinton were focused on policy and criminal behavior. Perhaps this is due to the fact that she’s already been in office so we know what we’re getting, as opposed to Trump who’s never been in office so one cannot comment on policy when he hasn’t enacted any yet. Any discussion about policy as far as Trump’s concerned is mere assumption and projection. I also noticed that every personality description you make for Trump can also be seen in Clinton – narcissistic, crude, and generally unchristian.
Why not take a chance on someone who has yet to prove himself in office and seems genuinelly willing to im-prove himself and our country? Babies “torn limb from limb” should make any person with a pulse cringe, especially Christians, much more than the reality that Trump is seeking their vote. At least he’s extending himself to them. After all, the Christian way is forgiving, charitable and patient, especially to those who show remorse, which Trump has done but Clinton has not. I’ve certainly had some conversations I’m ashamed of, especially during the time in my life when I was not as faithful as I am now. Although Trump is in need of polish, refinement and communication skills he’s surrounded himself with the likes of many Christian politicians and advisors, whereas Clinton has shown disdain for Catholics and Christians.
When I pull the lever I’m doing so more for the conservative beliefs that I hold dear as a Catholic, which happen to align more with the Republican party. If you like Pence, a vote for Trump is a vote for him as well all the others supporting him.
A really good article. Actually, a great article.
As a corporate CEO, Trump has given the world a glimpse at his policy. That position is always a political one. They don’t manage the business… They hire people to do that. They essentially represent the shareholders/stakeholders to the Corporation. It’s more or less a governorship. In this respect, Trump has demonstrated a proficiency, albeit one that can only be measured in dollar signs. And this is where I have my greatest reservations about Trump. I am opposed to the mere existence of publicly traded corporations with legal personhood. If the corporation is its own legal entity, then its brain can only think in terms of profit. There’s no room for secondary considerations, like whether or not something is right or wrong. I fear that Trump has been conditioned to this exact mentality.
I think Trump might make some improvements to the economy… maybe. But this is not a guy who will champion the cause against evil, and that evil is reaching a boiling point. The Revolutionary Movement of the past several hundred years has consistently either sidelined or thrown away God from society. We’ve tried desperately to build a solid societal foundation on something that is not at all solid. Collapse is inevitable, the only question is when. And the old, reliable delay tactics are failing. More than half the world is teetering on the brink of chaos and full-scale war. Do I think Trump can hold back that tide? Not even a little bit.
My primary concern (as I’ve already served in the military), will be looking for a spot to rebuild once the dust settles… Assuming my family and I make it through.
The appointment of Supreme Court Justices also figures into the mix.
God bless you for your biblical emphasis on principle and faith in God as He has revealed Himself, not fear!
Well said by a brave young Catholic.
Everyone please remember that you need not vote every category on the ballot. You may leave the presidency blank. Your votes for good men and women in the other categories will be counted.
I always take comfort in these biblical statements: “Whose face is engraved on this coin?” (Note a coin has two sides) Give to them what belongs to them and give to God what belongs to God. His kingdom is not of this world. ‘Let the people decide’ – Pontius Pilate.
The people who will not vote for any President scare me because by their inaction they will only be helping the one they least want to get into office. If you can’t vote *for* someone, cast your vote *against* the other candidate. Vote for the platform, not the godless ideology the other side wishes to force upon us all. May God have mercy on our country!